Sesame Street Stuffed Animals

15,428 Results

2003 Nanco Sesame Street Grover HUGE 45" stuffed Animal Niagara falls t shirt
$70.00
or Best Offer
$13.00 shipping
+3^ &J *I K] w.?U!N |/N $S p o n s o r e d
KAWS x Big Bird Sesame Street Uniqlo Plush Toy Limited Edition Stuffed Animal
$70.00
or Best Offer
$10.36 shipping
+5R^ &* ]0E w.9?S! 80 E|/V $S p o n s o r e d
Sesame Street Official Cookie Monster Soft Plush, Premium Plush Toy , 13 inch
$22.99
Free shipping
80 sold
L+K^ & *7 ] wQ DM. ?N!W V1| / $S p o n s o r e d
Fisher Price Sesame Street TMX Friend Tickle Me Ernie
$49.99
or Best Offer
Free shipping
+^5 E& D* U JT] w 8I. ?!|L/ $S p o n s o r e d
Sesame Street Ovejita Classic Character Collection 14" Plush EUC ADULT OWNED
$235.00
or Best Offer
$7.67 shipping
+^L9 K2 Y&*T ] w.WF? H!|X/ $
Applause Sesame Street Monsterpiece Theater Alistair Cookie Monster Plush
$59.99
or Best Offer
$14.99 shipping
+J0^ &*6 ]U RwB.? !R|8/ XQ $
Sesame Street Mr. Snuffleupagus (Snuffy) and Big Bird Plushies!
$29.99
or Best Offer
$9.29 shipping
+8R ^OB &*7 ]N wO8 R.?!I|/ $
New Two Headed Monster Plush Exclusive Sesame Street Place Busch Gardens NWT 16"
$65.00
$9.45 shipping
29 watching
+8C^ AM& *J W] Jw.R W?1 !|/ $
Kith x Sesame Street Plush Set Multi
$190.00
or Best Offer
$9.88 shipping
14 watching
+D^4 W X&* 5B ] 9 w.?!|I/ $
Sesame Street Fisher Price Cookie Monster 12" Plush; 2005, Soft, All Plush Safe
$12.95
Free shipping
4+U N^ &* 4] Pw.?!C| / $V
2025 SHERLOCK HEMLOCK Sesame Street 20" Plush NWT Seaworld Exclusive
$61.20
Was: $68.00was - US $68.00
$14.00 shipping
Only 1 left!
D+B^ 2F&* TX] w6.4 V?B!| / $
NEW 2015 Herry Monster Sesame Place Plush Sesame Workshop Seaworld Exclusive TAG
$149.99
or Best Offer
Free shipping
+F9^ 0 &K* Q9 ] w .C?4!| GK / $
Kith x Sesame Street Kith and Play Elmo Plush- BRAND NEW
$69.99
or Best Offer
$5.99 shipping
7+9^ 36 G&*L ] w.?Y9! |/ $
Fisher Price Sesame Street TMX Friend Tickle Me Cookie Monster
$54.99
or Best Offer
Free shipping
F+^ &* ] 9 Nw.N?! |/5 B$ AP S p o n s o r e d
Sesame Street Baby Natasha Posable Plush Doll 12"
$250.00
or Best Offer
$13.00 shipping
12 watching
Y+^W & * 8A] 78w.?!|/ $2VS p o n s o r e d
Fisher Price Sesame Street TMX Friend Tickle Me Elmo
$39.99
or Best Offer
Free shipping
SO +^ 58&* NN ] 3Bw GF. ?!|/ $S p o n s o r e d
2025 SHERLOCK HEMLOCK Sesame Street 20" Plush NWT Seaworld Exclusive
$62.99
or Best Offer
$7.00 shipping
+^ &Q* ]S w IG.?!|/ $ S
Isaac Mizrahi Loves Sesame Street Big Bird 16" Plush Stuffed Doll Toy 2019
$19.99
or Best Offer
$6.36 shipping
9K +O^I 5&*W ] w.?! Q|/ 6$
Fiesta Cutie Beans sesame place Sesame Street Elmo Ernie big bird count
$250.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping
+8^ &5 F*M ]3C w.?B!|/X 4$
Lot of 7 TYCO Beans Sesame Street 7" Stuffed Beany Toy Plush Vintage 1997
$49.99
or Best Offer
$9.99 shipping
+F^1 & * V]4 w TU.?!|/ $2C
2007 Singing Pizza Elmo SESAME STREET Fisher Price Animated Music - Works!
(5)
$60.00
$26.40 shipping
L6+ 17^ &* ] w.?CM!|/ J$
New Two Headed Monster Plush Exclusive Sesame Street Place Stuffed Animal
$68.00
$14.00 shipping
B5+ ^ &* ]O I w52. ?!HT| 4/A $
Sesame Street Place Pink Telly Monster Plush 17" 2012
$46.99
$7.38 shipping
+5X^ & *G U] wN.?!|3 /I $2
Vintage Sesame Street Ernie Hand Puppet 1973 Jim Henson Muppets w/ Box
$220.00
Free shipping
+^ DZ &VD 4* B ] w.?H!|/D $
Vintage 1997 Tyco "Sesame Street Beans" Lot 12 Plush New With Tags NWT
$44.99
$12.99 shipping
+G^8 & *V C ZB] Y 7w .?!|RG / $
Rare Vintage 1986 Sesame Street Big Bird 13" Plush Toy Doll Playskool
$24.99
or Best Offer
$5.21 shipping
13 watching
AP+^ 0&N* ] ZW w. S?!M 9|9 / $
Sesame Street Ovejita Lamb Classic Character Collection Plush
$229.00
$11.40 shipping
+4^ &* 5] wQ.V? !|VV/ $
Sesame Street Abby Cadabby Ladybug & Gonger Chef Place Seaworld 15” Plush Lot
$45.00
or Best Offer
$7.67 shipping
CZ +HT ^ &* ] 6w.D?!|/ F$X
SLIMEY the Worm Plush.18" Plush. New with tag.Slimey the Worm
$60.00
or Best Offer
$7.01 shipping
14 watching
+^Q &J I*U ] wO.?!T |/4Z W $S p o n s o r e d
Jumbo 28" Tickle me Elmo Mattel Fisher Price 2002 Sesame Street Workshop WORKS
$39.99
or Best Offer
$16.91 shipping
+4K^ &* ] Ow.V?! |H/Z Y$I
Sesame Street Place BABY BEAR 16" Plush Stuffed Animal Rare HTF 2016
$69.99
Free shipping
19 watching
F7+^ 5 &X * I] wT .Y?V! |/G $
Vintage 1971 Sesame Street Jim Henson Muppets Big Bird Puppet by Topper Toys 19"
$62.00
or Best Offer
$10.65 shipping
+X^ &R *H ] wW SA 4E.?!| K/ $
Sesame Street Workshop 2013 Bert Burt Plush Toy 10" Hasbro Stuffed Muppets
$17.95
or Best Offer
Free shipping
+^Y W& *JG Z]5 w .R?!|Y/ $
Sesame Street gund Burt And Ernie Set Plush 2019 14 Inches Ernie 15 Inches Ernie
$19.66
or Best Offer
$5.94 shipping
+Q^ R&* ] wTH 9.V J?!X |/GM $
NWT Rare Cookie Monster Sesame Street Hot Pink 🩷 Plush Stuffed Toy Factory 9”
$19.99
or Best Offer
$7.99 shipping
+JX^ 8&* X] w.?! 0|/ $F
New SLIMEY the Worm Plush Exclusive Sesame Street Place Stuffed Animal NWT
$61.20
Was: $68.00was - US $68.00
$14.00 shipping
4+T ^M C&* ]5 3w .?!|Z3/ $
NEW Gund Mini Cookie Monster Plush 075933 Sesame Street 5” Stuffed Toy w/Tag
$12.50
Free shipping
+^ &T*L M ] P 9Jw V.V?! 2|6 / $
Vintage Fisher-Price Sesame Street Elmo, Mr. Noodle & Dorothy Stuffed Plush NEW!
$297.08
Was: $349.50was - US $349.50
or Best Offer
$7.99 shipping
12 watching
KG +96^ &* I 4] w.?! I|Y / 8$
Sesame Street Place 13" The Count Plush Seaworld Busch Gardens
$17.95
$5.31 shipping
8+^ M&* ] w M.R?! AI| 6/X $S p o n s o r e d
Kidrobot x Sesame Street x Phunny 13" Seated COOKIE MONSTER Plush Stuffed Animal
$12.99
$6.05 shipping
+^ &*F ]X M B S6 w.?P!P 8|Z/ $
Sesame Street Gund Abby Cadabby Plush Doll w wins 6 inch
$25.00
or Best Offer
$4.33 shipping
+^AY &* ] w .P?!|D /14 $ BG
Sesame Street Prairie Dawn Plush Doll Pink Yellow Yarn Hair Sesame Place 16"
$69.95
$5.79 shipping
05 ED+^ &* ]Z S MRw.?! |/ $
Plaza Sesamo Abelardo Plush RARE HTF Applause 1997 FREE SHIPPING!
$199.99
Free shipping
+^ &*J 3] w .?!0A| /E F$
NEW Vintage 1996 Tyco Talking Big Bird Plush Toy 16" Sesame Street Playtime
$31.50
or Best Offer
$7.79 shipping
0+^Y &* Z] w.?!0|/ $V8
Sesame Street Plushy Collection Of 10 Plushies, 3 New And 7 In Great Condition
$39.00
or Best Offer
$8.00 shipping
O+S L^J &* 4]U Q1 w.Q6?! |/ $
Lot 4 Sesame Street Plush Ernie, Cookie Monster, Big Bird, Elmo Applause Namco
$23.99
or Best Offer
$11.78 shipping
+P^N &Y* I 4] wL. BG?!|/ 2R $
Tyco Tickle Me Zoe Vintage Works Sesame Street In Original Box 90s
$59.99
or Best Offer
$10.67 shipping
IA I7+^ &* R] R wC.?O!| Y/ $
Vintage Applause Count Von Count Plush Toy Sesame Street Original Tag Hands
$46.92
or Best Offer
$6.36 shipping
+F^ 4 &*73 ] ZwB. ?!|/R5 $
Sesame Street Place Rosita Plush 16" Toy Work shop Spanish Girl 2012 One Spot
$89.99
$8.85 shipping
+^ F&* ] Z RwG .?!Z|/O $
Skinless Sesame Street Elmo Slide Singing and Dancing Plush English Spanish
$15.00
Free shipping
N+^S D&* P] Jw.?H! |/0 $B
Lot of 5 Playskool/Tyco Sesame Street Beanie Plush Big Bird Elmo cookie monster
$30.00
or Best Offer
$14.40 shipping
+^6 F Y&H * 3] w8.? !|/ $1K
1997 Sesame Street Sherlock Hemlock Bean Bag Plush TYCO 9" Plush Toy
(17)
$0.99
$6.30 shipping
1 bid
1h 12m
+A7^ 3 &*P M] w8 .O?!K|/ $
New ZOE Plush Orange Sesame Street Place Character NWT 13"
$49.00
$12.00 shipping
+^ &*H N ]X0 w. C?O! |/CW $
Kohl's Cares Sesame Street Big Bird Plush 14 Inches New
$7.50
or Buy It Now
$6.40 shipping
0 bids
1h 11m
I+^5 &M*0 2I] w.?F!K| J/0 $
Sesame Street Abby Cadabby Stuffed Plush Toy Animal Doll 11" 50 Years NWT
$18.23
or Best Offer
$7.00 shipping
+PA^ I &T * ]LY w.?! |/ $C
Vintage Sesame Street Playskool Nap Mat Big Bird Nap Pal 551 37”x22” RARE
$45.00
or Best Offer
$6.53 shipping
BJ+^ S&*H F ]1 w.?!|X7 /N $
Sesame Street Big Bird Pirate Plush Stuffed Animal 12” Nanco 2007
$12.87
Was: $13.99was - US $13.99
or Best Offer
$6.50 shipping
+Y^2 A7&* ] 4w.Q ?!|/ D$E
Vintage 1985 Bert Ernie Stuffed Animal Plush Dolls Applause 6" Best Friends
$49.85
$5.21 shipping
XO+ ^ &* ] w3.?!|E/ ZL$
LOT 11 Vintage ELMO Plush Collection Including Rare Tickle Me Elmo
$98.99
or Best Offer
$149.35 shipping
A+^2 & * ] Gw.?!|/ M L2 FR $S p o n s o r e d
Gund Sesame Street Grover 14” Stuffed Animal Plush Vintage 2002
$14.44
or Best Offer
$5.23 shipping
+^ &* ]J w.7?! |/Y5 GF$ SO S p o n s o r e d

Best Selling

See All

TYCO Sesame Street Beans 9 in Plush Toy
(17)
$9.99 New
$8.45 Used
Cookie Monster 8” Kidrobot Plush Window Clinger Sesame Street
$16.99 New
Gund Sesame Street TANGO Puppy Plush Elmo Dog Furry Friends Forever Muppets J3
$25.99 New
$22.00 Used
Hasbro C0923 Tickle Me Elmo Plush Toy - Red
(90)
$55.00 New
$3.95 Used
2 50th Anniversary Sesame Street Surprise Plush GUND Big Bird RARE Prairie Dawn
(1)
$5.00 New
GUND Sesame Street Count Beanbag Stuffed Animal M9
(17)
$12.00 New
1996 TYCO Tickle Me Big Bird Sesame Street Plush Electronic Laughs & Shakes
(1)
$29.99 New
$18.00 Used
Fisher Ctw Sesame Street Rock & Roll Ernie Toy Plush 1998 Tyco Mattel
(2)
$44.95 New

Top Rated

See All

Hasbro C0923 Tickle Me Elmo Plush Toy - Red
(90)

97% agree - Durable
$55.00 New
$3.95 Used
TYCO Sesame Street Beans 9 in Plush Toy
(17)

100% agree - Would recommend
$9.99 New
$8.45 Used
GUND Oscar The Grouch Green Silver Garbage Can 10 Inch Stuffed Plush 2003
(13)

100% agree - Durable
$18.00 New
$13.99 Used
GUND Sesame Street Count Beanbag Stuffed Animal M9
(17)

100% agree - Durable
$12.00 New

Motors

Clothing & Accessories

Sporting goods

Electronics

Business & Industrial

Jewelry & Watches

Collectibles & Art

Home & garden

Other categories

Sesame Street Stuffed Animals

Shop by Category

15,428 Results

2003 Nanco Sesame Street Grover HUGE 45" stuffed Animal Niagara falls t shirt

KAWS x Big Bird Sesame Street Uniqlo Plush Toy Limited Edition Stuffed Animal

Sesame Street Official Cookie Monster Soft Plush, Premium Plush Toy , 13 inch

Fisher Price Sesame Street TMX Friend Tickle Me Ernie

Sesame Street Ovejita Classic Character Collection 14" Plush EUC ADULT OWNED

Applause Sesame Street Monsterpiece Theater Alistair Cookie Monster Plush

Sesame Street Mr. Snuffleupagus (Snuffy) and Big Bird Plushies!

New Two Headed Monster Plush Exclusive Sesame Street Place Busch Gardens NWT 16"

Kith x Sesame Street Plush Set Multi

Sesame Street Fisher Price Cookie Monster 12" Plush; 2005, Soft, All Plush Safe

2025 SHERLOCK HEMLOCK Sesame Street 20" Plush NWT Seaworld Exclusive

NEW 2015 Herry Monster Sesame Place Plush Sesame Workshop Seaworld Exclusive TAG

Kith x Sesame Street Kith and Play Elmo Plush- BRAND NEW

Fisher Price Sesame Street TMX Friend Tickle Me Cookie Monster

Sesame Street Baby Natasha Posable Plush Doll 12"

Fisher Price Sesame Street TMX Friend Tickle Me Elmo

2025 SHERLOCK HEMLOCK Sesame Street 20" Plush NWT Seaworld Exclusive

Isaac Mizrahi Loves Sesame Street Big Bird 16" Plush Stuffed Doll Toy 2019

Fiesta Cutie Beans sesame place Sesame Street Elmo Ernie big bird count

Lot of 7 TYCO Beans Sesame Street 7" Stuffed Beany Toy Plush Vintage 1997

2007 Singing Pizza Elmo SESAME STREET Fisher Price Animated Music - Works!

New Two Headed Monster Plush Exclusive Sesame Street Place Stuffed Animal

Sesame Street Place Pink Telly Monster Plush 17" 2012

Vintage Sesame Street Ernie Hand Puppet 1973 Jim Henson Muppets w/ Box

Vintage 1997 Tyco "Sesame Street Beans" Lot 12 Plush New With Tags NWT

Rare Vintage 1986 Sesame Street Big Bird 13" Plush Toy Doll Playskool

Sesame Street Ovejita Lamb Classic Character Collection Plush

Sesame Street Abby Cadabby Ladybug & Gonger Chef Place Seaworld 15” Plush Lot

SLIMEY the Worm Plush.18" Plush. New with tag.Slimey the Worm

Jumbo 28" Tickle me Elmo Mattel Fisher Price 2002 Sesame Street Workshop WORKS

Sesame Street Place BABY BEAR 16" Plush Stuffed Animal Rare HTF 2016

Vintage 1971 Sesame Street Jim Henson Muppets Big Bird Puppet by Topper Toys 19"

Sesame Street Workshop 2013 Bert Burt Plush Toy 10" Hasbro Stuffed Muppets

Sesame Street gund Burt And Ernie Set Plush 2019 14 Inches Ernie 15 Inches Ernie

NWT Rare Cookie Monster Sesame Street Hot Pink 🩷 Plush Stuffed Toy Factory 9”

New SLIMEY the Worm Plush Exclusive Sesame Street Place Stuffed Animal NWT

NEW Gund Mini Cookie Monster Plush 075933 Sesame Street 5” Stuffed Toy w/Tag

Vintage Fisher-Price Sesame Street Elmo, Mr. Noodle & Dorothy Stuffed Plush NEW!

Sesame Street Place 13" The Count Plush Seaworld Busch Gardens

Kidrobot x Sesame Street x Phunny 13" Seated COOKIE MONSTER Plush Stuffed Animal

Sesame Street Gund Abby Cadabby Plush Doll w wins 6 inch

Sesame Street Prairie Dawn Plush Doll Pink Yellow Yarn Hair Sesame Place 16"

Plaza Sesamo Abelardo Plush RARE HTF Applause 1997 FREE SHIPPING!

NEW Vintage 1996 Tyco Talking Big Bird Plush Toy 16" Sesame Street Playtime

Sesame Street Plushy Collection Of 10 Plushies, 3 New And 7 In Great Condition ￼

Lot 4 Sesame Street Plush Ernie, Cookie Monster, Big Bird, Elmo Applause Namco

Tyco Tickle Me Zoe Vintage Works Sesame Street In Original Box 90s

Vintage Applause Count Von Count Plush Toy Sesame Street Original Tag Hands

Sesame Street Place Rosita Plush 16" Toy Work shop Spanish Girl 2012 One Spot

Skinless Sesame Street Elmo Slide Singing and Dancing Plush English Spanish

Lot of 5 Playskool/Tyco Sesame Street Beanie Plush Big Bird Elmo cookie monster

1997 Sesame Street Sherlock Hemlock Bean Bag Plush TYCO 9" Plush Toy

New ZOE Plush Orange Sesame Street Place Character NWT 13"

Kohl's Cares Sesame Street Big Bird Plush 14 Inches New

Sesame Street Abby Cadabby Stuffed Plush Toy Animal Doll 11" 50 Years NWT

Vintage Sesame Street Playskool Nap Mat Big Bird Nap Pal 551 37”x22” RARE

Sesame Street Big Bird Pirate Plush Stuffed Animal 12” Nanco 2007

Vintage 1985 Bert Ernie Stuffed Animal Plush Dolls Applause 6" Best Friends

LOT 11 Vintage ELMO Plush Collection Including Rare Tickle Me Elmo

Gund Sesame Street Grover 14” Stuffed Animal Plush Vintage 2002

Best Selling

TYCO Sesame Street Beans 9 in Plush Toy

Cookie Monster 8” Kidrobot Plush Window Clinger Sesame Street

Gund Sesame Street TANGO Puppy Plush Elmo Dog Furry Friends Forever Muppets J3

Hasbro C0923 Tickle Me Elmo Plush Toy - Red

2 50th Anniversary Sesame Street Surprise Plush GUND Big Bird RARE Prairie Dawn

GUND Sesame Street Count Beanbag Stuffed Animal M9

1996 TYCO Tickle Me Big Bird Sesame Street Plush Electronic Laughs & Shakes

Sesame Street Plushy Collection Of 10 Plushies, 3 New And 7 In Great Condition